Daily Archives: November 5, 2026

Letter from a Kansan: “Would You Rather Be Right or Happy?”

As a person that has lived in Kansas almost all my life, I have never seen such good political news for this state as we got this week. It is a stunning rebuke of fascism from across the country.

One of the many pieces of wisdom from mechanic Tom Magliozzi is this question: “Would you rather be right, or happy?” He often asked it in the context of somebody that had just won an argument.

This is my plea to all our progressive friends: remember that question, and keep it in mind carefully over the next 2 years. We can either build on this momentum for an even bigger victory in 2028, or we can start to lose this unique coalition.

Kansans spend our lives being misunderstood and forgotten.

Many of us, myself included, visit large cities regularly.

It is a more surprising event when someone from a large city drives down one of our dirt roads. The kind of road that leaves your car covered in mud when you drive your daughter to school. The kind of road that we drive on for 3 miles before we reach the nearest paved road.

Statisticians label Topeka, the capital of Kansas and city of 126,000 people, as rural.

The nearst town to me, 7 miles away, has a population of 600. In winter, many people here still leave their keys in their running, unlocked cars while they run into the grocery store. The person at the bank, the owner of the grocery store, the mechanic, the electricians, the builders, the people that run the local museum, all know my name and recognize me. Not because I’m famous locally, but because this is normal here. We are a community, a real one.

Yet I’ve lost long-time friends, especially from the west coast, because, while I’m progressive, I still talk to Republicans. They thought Republicans are so evil, they ought to be shunned and ostracized.

It probably doesn’t compute to a San Franciscan what it means to live in a county that went 80% for Trump one time. A county of about 10,000 people living in a space larger than Los Angeles, New York, and San Jose — combined. (Those cities have a combined population of about 13 million, living on the same amount of land as 10,000 people do out here.)

If I avoided talking to Republicans, it wouldn’t be them that would be isolated. It would be me.

Out here, many of us have lived with each other for generations. We may go on living with them for generations. If somebody’s car is stuck in the mud, the first person that comes by with a truck and a rope will probably pull them out. Nobody asks who you voted for. This is what you do for neighbors, because neighbors are humans, and next time it might be me that’s stuck in the mud.

I can be as incensed as anyone else about what the fascists are doing. I don’t have direct knowledge of how a lot of people vote. But I take a deep breath sometimes and remind myself: these are my neighbors. I’ve seen them go out of their way to be kind and generous with all walks of humanity. (Yes, even whatever groups you’re imaginging to argue with me about.)

This is part of how Adam Hamilton defeated Roger Marshal. The anti-Trump sentiment wasn’t enough on its own. Lifelong Republicans dissatisfied with how Trump handled things weren’t just going to vote for any Democrat. They needed someone that was safe. Someone that talked to them as humans. Someone that respected them.

Adam Hamilton went and shook hands with MAGA protestors at his events. He told them “I want to be your senator, too.”

This is how you win over the most strident of Republicans. Hamilton didn’t compromise his beliefs. He invited discussion about them.

I have already been seeing some progressives say things like, “Don’t cut them any slack. Remember how many times people voted for fascism! They need to still be ostracized.”

That, folks, is the way we lose. It is the wrong strategy everywhere. And it is especially culturally wrong in the close-knit communities — again, actual communities where people know each other and have for years — that make up the heartland.

Building relationships with people different than us is our best chance to build on this coalition. And, isn’t that what progressive values call for?

So, celebrate this victory. Clap for all the activists that made it happen.

And, before you set off to alienate your new and tentative allies, ask yourself:

“Would I rather be right? Or win again?”